Montclair is a mid-size pocket of roughly 7,236 households, small enough that the opener failures we see aren't random - they cluster by age. The median house here dates to around 1990, which means a lot of original or first-replacement openers are chain-drive units from the 1990s and early 2000s, now on their second or third motor gear set. That gear set is usually the first thing to go. It's a nylon part meant to strip before the motor burns out, and on a unit this old it's often stripped already, which shows up as a motor that hums but doesn't move the door.
Cold plays a part too. This area sits in a climate zone the federal data flags as cold and severe, and an opener in an unheated or semi-conditioned garage deals with grease that thickens in January and sensor lenses that fog or ice over. Both cause the same complaint: the door won't close, or it closes and reverses for no obvious reason. Neither is usually the opener itself failing - it's the opener reacting correctly to something else going stiff or misaligned around it. That distinction matters because it changes whether you're replacing a $20 sensor or a $150 logic board.